Powered By Blogger

Saturday, September 11, 2010

Will A New Breed Of Innovation Companies Eventually Settle Into The Realm Of New Product/Service Innovation?

Picture 18
The last few years we’ve seen a growing interest on “design” and “design thinking” although we don’t see MBA school rushing to teach using “design thinking” application in business problem solving. Design influence has not only infiltrate B-schools, it has attracted the interest of ad agencies and branding agencies. It is a marketer’s dream to have products that do not require advertising, the balance of form and function itself that consumers recognize instantly, that's will never happen of it does it is rare. Even Apple needs to advertise so adverting is not going away. Except it's very nature has changed. Marketing, in the form of logos, packaging, advertising, and the ever-broadening fuzzy activities known as branding, has attained the status of necessary evil to build brands.
We’re seeing some branding agencies (and adv agencies) are trying to get into products, some are doing a more decent jobs than others. There are some ex-agency creative folks carrying the banner of Corporate Social Responsibility consultants and all they can think of is the obvious. I think branding firm and even ad firm (with a few exceptions) are not right for the job, the same reasons why you won’t hire your lawyer to fix your customer service problems or your accountants to fix your technology problems. Mark Read (WPP corporate) reminded me that some 20 years back ad agency (Bates) helped De Beers to come up with many of the innovation. They pretty much invented the ritual and came up with phrase 'a diamond is forever' and that people have used diamond engagement rings ever since. But when the last time we’ve seen an innovation came from an agency?
Can adv agencies design great products and/or experiences? You would think so? Over the years they have narrowed their skills (rather than broadening) and their core capabilities were reduced to doing the following three things 1/ finding a unique way to positioning a products within its category 2/adjustments of minutia to affect the consumers’ perception of the brand 3/ maximize repetitive exposure and extend reach. Innovation is not a core capability. Deep customer insight is not a core capability (over reliance of traditional research is the problem). Customer engagement is not a core capability (although they refer customer engagement as engaging through a 30sec TVC). It makes you wonder whether a new breed innovation companies will eventually settle into the realm of new product innovation and brand / communication innovation or even push into the space to deliver business model innovation.

No comments:

Post a Comment